I am riding the train to Pleasantville to the Jacob Burns Film Center,
where the first three hours of FLYING is playing tonight. Outside it is
dark and rainy and the sound of the train brings back memories. When I
was a girl, I remember how precarious life could be: little things had
huge effects and might change the course of where I was going – without
me even realizing it.
I remember the first summer my parents sent me to sleep-away camp.
My brother had gone the year before, and I couldn’t wait to be in his
shoes, even though he hated it and threatened to run away before he’d
go to camp again. You see, my father had gone to camp when he was
growing up, so we all had to go. Later in life, I heard it was a Jewish
thing: Jews sent their children out of the city to make them physically
strong while the parents toiled all summer in the hot steaming,
concrete world of the mind. But as a girl, I knew nothing about the
reasoning behind my parent’s decision – and my desire to go to camp had
nothing to do with my father. Already, at nine years old, I couldn’t
wait to be away on my own. I dreamed of freedom, and I saw camp as the
first step… then I would go to college…. and then I would travel the world….
The place my parents sent me was an all-girl’s camp on a hill in
Maine that sloped down to a lake – something all good Jewish camps must
adjoin. Water sports were essential to wholesomeness: here I would
learn to swim, sail, water ski, have camp fires on the shores and do
all the things I (and they) had seen in the movies. The cabins made a
straight line down to the shore and the order showed the lake’s
importance: the older girl’s bunks were right on the water’s edge so
they could croon over the moon at night, while the bunks decreased in
age up the hill until the youngest girl’s bunk was the farthest away
from the water. That was of course my bunk – the puny kids.
When I arrived, I felt like I was in heaven. My mom had packed a
whole black steamer trunk full of things for me to use for the eight
weeks I would be there. She had bought me a uniform of gray shorts and
white t-shirts with little monograms of the camp on it. And a green
sweater with the same monogram in the center of my chest for when it
got cold. Best of all, stowed inside was a pair of new tan riding
jodhpurs and new riding shoes whose leather creaked when I walked. My
mother had signed me up ahead of time for the special riding classes,
which took place off the campgrounds.
I don’t remember saying goodbye to my parents and I don’t remember
caring that they left. In fact – I don’t think the thought of
homesickness even crossed my mind once. By some stroke of luck, I was
assigned a bed by the far wall – surely the coziest spot in the room.
You could lean your back against the wooden panels and only have one
other bed beside you. The first few days I had some squabbles with one
of the other girls, but nothing too daunting I thought. In fact I can’t
remember what it was about – perhaps she wanted my wonderful cot? Or
perhaps it was because I had bucked teeth and couldn’t close my mouth
when I chewed my food? Or, perhaps, now that I think of it, she was
teasing me because I still wet my bed and the counselor had to get up
in the middle of the night to help me change my sheets a few times.
Yes, it was the girl who slept next to me and the noise of me getting
up wet woke her up. Of course I was mortified, but I couldn’t do
anything to make it stop – or her stop. She must have told the whole
bunk. Still I didn’t think it was that bad. Things would die down – I
loved being at camp; I couldn’t wait for my first campfire and sing
along. I remember the first riding lesson I had and the smell of manure
as I walked across the stable to mount my horse.
Until one day, my bunk counselor asked me
if I’d like to move my bed closer to her to get away from the girl in
the cot beside me making fun of me. I didn’t think it was so necessary,
but I remembered feeling vaguely flattered by the attention, so I said,
“Ok.” The next thing I knew, I was sleeping on a cot in the middle of
the room surrounded by other cots. Suddenly, I was very exposed. I
longed for my lovely place by the wall but it was too late to get it
back. Now that the counselor had me sleeping by her bed, the teasing
from all the other girls led by the first girl who now had my bed,
started for real. I was called, “Little Pet” and taunted that I was
getting special privileges. Of course my bed-wetting increased, which
gave my bunkmates more to whisper about and laugh at me each time I
passed them. Now, the counselor came up with a new plan: perhaps I
should change bunks to get away from these horrid girls? Not knowing
how to stop the escalating attacks, I agreed. Suddenly I had to pack up
all my new and perfect camp clothes – and four counselors picked up the
heavy trunk just like a casket and carried it out the door to the next
bunk one step closer to the lake and filled with strange girls who were
older than me – by two years.
Of course, I was completely doomed before the counselors even put my
trunk down. I had no idea the gulf between a nine year old and an
eleven year old. The girls in my new bunk were, among other things,
already wearing training bras – something I had never even heard of and
had absolutely not developed a need for. The older girls knew words my
young friends and I didn’t even know the meaning for. They knew how to
inflict pain in ways I could not have dreamed. Since my very coming to
their territory already labeled me as a sissy, a sellout, a tattletale,
there was nothing to do but face the price of what I had done. Because
if I haven’t mentioned it yet, my previous bunk was punished for how
they treated me and were put on a kind of ‘inner camp detention’,
blocked of any special privileges, including desert, for one week. Now
only one thing was clear to me: say anything to a counselor about how I
was being treated by my new bunkmates and I would not survive my first
summer in camp.
And that’s about when my memory of any camp activities stopped. Did
I learn to swim? Did I sit by the campfire? Did I get to go riding a
second time? I vaguely remember a huge mess hall, but what happened to
me in there, I have no idea. It was all about survival – and survival
meant keeping all eyes pinned on the faces of these girls I had to live
with to try to be ready for the next blow. The small ones, like
stealing my favorite stuffed animal and rolling him in mud behind the
cabin before tossing him in the waste basket, to sabotaging my bed
sheet so I couldn’t put my feet in it, to the larger ones, which always
fell in the realm of verbal mental torture. The high point came one day
when the three toughest girls surrounded me, during our “rest period”
after lunch, that time when we all were supposed to be on our beds
safely napping with our eyes shut. Of course, the counselor had left
the bunk.
My eyes were shut until the hissing began above me: There as I
opened my eyes were three twisted girls’ faces staring at me. They
wanted to discuss one thing and one thing only, very simple: did I know
where babies came from? They were sure I was too stupid to know even
this simple fact.
I remember sitting up in bed and barely blinking. Then I said the
only thing I could say: Of course I knew. My mom had four children (the
fifth was on the way) and she had told me everything. They snickered
and their lips curled. “Well, then tell us?” the tallest one said with
a grin. I think I stood up at that point, just to get some leverage. I
carefully explained what my mom had told – at least what I remembered
she had told me – it was hard to remember much with the three girls
faces pressing towards me. And what I said to them was obvious: when my
mom and dad wanted a baby they prayed to god and that god put a seed in
mom’s belly that then grew into a baby.
The three girls shrieked with delight. “No!” The second tallest girl
said: “When your Mom and Dad want a baby your dad puts his wonky wet
penis in her ugly vagina and then he squirts out little gray seeds and
that’s how she gets pregnant!” The three girls started to laugh and
slapped each other on the back. How stupid could this ugly bucked tooth
girl be? I don’t know what my face must have looked like: Shocked?
Confused? Outraged? The thought of what they had said was too
horrifying. I screamed at them all: “That’s not true! My mom and Dad
don’t do that!” Then I covered my ears and ran out of the bunk into the
empty, stillness outside. There was not a soul in sight since everyone
was asleep in their bunks. I found a large rock not far from the cabin,
sat down on it, and cried hysterically. It was the most awful thing I
had ever heard, yet in my heart, despite the fact I had denied it to
the girls faces, I knew they were right – my mom and dad did that
horrible thing. And I hated my mom for not telling me the truth and
leaving me exposed to this type of ridicule.
Somehow I fell ill and was taken to stay in the camp infirmary for
days. No one could figure out what was wrong with me. I was driven to
the hospital several times in the middle of the night with a high
fever, but nothing was ever determined. They thought I had Strepthroat
and might need my tonsils removed. There was a beautiful nurse named
Karen who lived at the infirmary – well not actually beautiful, she had
a bit of a horsey face, but still she was very pretty. She had long,
long brown hair to her waist and kind eyes – and she treated me with a
lot of love.
I don’t know how I managed to remain sick for the rest of the
summer, but somehow I did. I don’t remember ever having to go back to
that bunk with the eleven year old girls – or if I did, it must have
been only for short periods and under the constant guard of a
counselor. I will always remember Karen driving me back and forth to
the hospital at odd hours for tests – and stopping for a soft ice cream
after the prodding and poking was over, on the way back to my infirmary
bed. Because in those days, if you had tonsillitis you got to eat a lot
of ice cream, which was a great solace for me.
In the middle of it all, one morning my parents suddenly showed up.
I was summoned to the house of the camp director way up above
everything on the very top of the hill. I remember the shock of seeing
my mom and dad sitting on two iron chairs in the middle of a vast green
lawn. My father took me on his lap and my mother stroked my knee. They
had something very sad to tell me they said. I had no idea what was
coming. Were they finally going to take me home? Did they realize my
suffering? I had written them letters telling them things weren’t going
so well, hadn’t I? Maybe now I could tell my mom how angry I was at
her! But there was no time for that.
My first cousin Jimmy, who was 13, had been hit by a car and killed.
I was so shocked. I don’t think I understood the meaning of death at
all, but still I burst out crying and I sobbed for a long time. They
would not take me to the funeral, they said; I was too young. I should
remain at camp, having a good time; everything would be fine; I should
stop crying. They didn’t look fine; they were ashen, but had decided
they must come to tell me. After a few moments, they would drive to see
my older brother Harry at his camp and break the bad news to him. And
then they left. I think I went back to the infirmary again – but
perhaps not. I didn’t know Jimmy that well; he was always much older
than me and didn’t play with little girls. But I was stunned
nonetheless. Somehow everything was put in its place with his death —
but I couldn’t tell you how exactly.
I made it through the eight weeks and went home. The next year my
parents sent me to a new girl’s summer camp and everything went fine.
This time I would not become the odd girl out, I was tougher now. I had
learned an important lesson – never let adults ‘save’ you. And what I
mean to say is this: somehow I understood very clearly that the problem
with that summer is that I played the victim with that first camp
counselor, and that act had made me into a victim for real the rest of
the summer. It was a downward spiral I couldn’t stop. I saw how
susceptible I was to pity, and to adult attention, but that their
helping hand actually undermined my ability to stand on my own feet. I
wondered to myself back then if every young girl was like me? So easily
knocked off her center by an adult? I was scared by my own perception
of the ease of my downfall: and I wasn’t sure I would be able to catch
myself next time. I tried to make myself vow that I would never be a
victim. But I wasn’t sure I could hold to it. I didn’t have this word –
victim — for it then. I just knew to be careful, vigilant of my needs
to be cared for rather than standing on my own feet.
And now as an adult I realize something else: it is so good that my
parents didn’t come to take me out of camp and save me from my
suffering. I don’t know what they knew about how bad a time I was
having, but surely they must have known something. The camp must have
told my mother that I was practically living in the infirmary. It
couldn’t be that usual for a child to spend thirty days out of sixty on
her back? But somehow they knew enough not to get me out of it.
Whatever it was, living in the infirmary still meant I was making it
through the experience on my own feet, in my own strange way. And that
fact, would help me in the years to come when things – as life would
have it – got still harder.
I was wondering if anyone else has memories of ‘turning
points’ in their lives when they were young or now? Moments when their
lives could have gone one way and yet went another? I am very
interested in these moments and how we save ourselves from disaster or
transform disaster into good. I’d love to hear your stories.